Dear Liar: A Play on Pygmalion's Original Eliza
In a captivating exploration of the relationship between George Bernard Shaw and Eliza Doolittle, the play 'Dear Liar' brings to life a fascinating chapter from the playwright's life. During World War II, Jerome Kilty, a US Army officer stationed in London, encountered the octogenarian Shaw, who warmly welcomed him. This encounter sparked Kilty's lifelong passion for the arts, leading him to become an actor and playwright. The play is inspired by Shaw's intense yet unfulfilled correspondence with Mrs. Patrick Campbell, the original Eliza in Pygmalion.
The revival of 'Dear Liar' showcases the complex dynamics between Shaw and Campbell through the performances of Rachel Pickup and Alan Turkington. Their portrayal of these larger-than-life personalities adds a layer of drama to the story. The first act focuses on the challenges of staging Pygmalion, with Campbell's contractual demands and Shaw's passionate negotiations. The tension between them is palpable, as they engage in verbal sparring, each determined to have their way.
As the play progresses, the relationship between Shaw and Campbell takes a turn. Their attempts to immortalize their connection through play or memoir create a rift in their bond. Shaw's curiosity leads him to witness his mother's cremation, while Campbell's loss in the war sparks a clash of ideologies, as Shaw's pacifism contrasts with Campbell's grief.
The modern interpretation of this material presents an interesting challenge. Scholars now view Campbell as a psychologically astute performer rather than a stroppy diva. However, the production by Stella Powell-Jones may not fully capture the essence of the script. While it has its moments of emotional depth, the declaiming dialogue can feel strained at times.
The set design, with its cloud-stippled curtains and calico-clad actors, creates a visually intriguing atmosphere. Pickup's portrayal of Campbell's aging beauty and Turkington's portrayal of Shaw's petulance add depth to their characters. The desire between them is palpable, but is it mere lust, as Campbell suggests? Their exchanges are filled with passion and imagination, yet the play struggles to fully capture the essence of their relationship.
'Dear Liar' is currently running at the Jermyn Street Theatre in London until March 7th. It offers a unique perspective on the life and relationships of one of the most influential playwrights in history, leaving audiences with a deeper understanding of Shaw's world.
