The Phillies franchise has a rich history, but some players who wore the red pinstripes are often forgotten. Uncovering these hidden gems is like discovering a secret chapter in the team's story. Let's delve into the team of stars who had their moments in Philly but are rarely remembered for it.
The Forgotten Phillies:
Catcher:
Benito Santiago, the 1996 catcher, had a stellar career before joining the Phillies. He was a 5-time All-Star, 3-time Gold Glove winner, and 4-time Silver Slugger with other teams. But his time in Philly was short-lived, with a solid 1996 season (2.9 WAR, 30 homers, 85 RBI) followed by a departure in 1997.
First Base:
Nap Lajoie's story is a fascinating one. He started his career in Philly but had a falling out with the penny-pinching ownership. He jumped to the Philadelphia Athletics in 1901, winning the Triple Crown and a batting title. Legal battles ensued, and he eventually played 13 years in Cleveland, securing his Hall of Fame status.
Second Base:
Joe Morgan, a Hall of Famer, had his accolades with the Reds. But his time in Philly at age 39 is notable. He won a pennant with the Phillies in 1983, joining Pete Rose, but his stats that year were arguably his worst.
Third Base:
Michael Young was acquired in 2012 to revive the glory days of the Phillies. However, the team struggled, and Young was traded after 126 games, hitting .276. The trade saga continued, with the acquired pitcher never playing for the Phillies.
Shortstop:
Dick Groat, a mid-century star, served in the military before becoming an MVP and World Series winner with the Pirates. His time in Philly was brief, hitting just .264, but it came after a significant trade that also brought the legendary broadcaster Bob Uecker to the team.
Outfielder:
Kenny Lofton is a curious case. He played exceptionally well in 2005, hitting .335, but his efforts were overshadowed by the team's young stars. Lofton's contribution to the Phillies' development is often overlooked.
Starting Pitcher:
Jake Arrieta, a former NL Cy Young winner, spent three seasons in Philly (2018-2020). His time with the team is easily forgotten, as he couldn't replicate his Chicago success, going 22-23 with a 4.36 ERA.
Relief Pitcher:
Gene Garber, a local hero from Lancaster, PA, dominated with the Braves and had a solid run with the Phillies in the 1970s. He joins a list of relievers who made an impact but are often underappreciated.
And there you have it—a team of Phillies stars who deserve a spotlight in the franchise's history. But here's where it gets controversial—were these players truly forgotten, or did they choose to leave a lesser legacy in Philly? Share your thoughts in the comments below. Is there a player you believe should be on this list, or do you have a different take on these forgotten heroes?
